Sunday, June 10, 2007

James vs. James: The Wall or Silence?

Wow, I really thought that Ironic would win, but it lost by a vote of 4-0! Now I ask is Silence still the forum favorite it once was, or would everyone rather climb The Wall?

My Personal Vote: Silence

5 comments:

Brian Erickson said...

The Wall has grown on me a LOT over the months, but my vote still goes to Silence.

Harry said...

"Silence" has such a beautiful writing, such a moving message and such an impacting ending that it is simply the best bait of all time. So my vote goes to "Silence" even though I really liked "The Wall" also.

Anonymous said...

Silence, no doubt. In my opinion, one of the top 5 best baits ever written.

zgamer said...

While Silence has grown on me more over the months, my vote goes to The Wall (I bet I'll be the only one to vote for it). Silence is a great personal account story, but The Wall just seems like a perfect baity project. It has an ideal director choice, an interesting plot and one of the most beautiful posters I have seen on the site. The leads are not my first choice, but that's only a small detail for a great bait.

So The Wall is my choice.

Anonymous said...

You write very well.